Like Button

I got more likes on Instagram. Here’s what actually worked for me.

Written by

in

Hi, I’m Kayla. I post coffee, small city life, and cozy outfits. For a long time, my photos sat at 90 to 150 likes. Not bad, but stale. So I ran a six-week test. I tried new post types, times, tools, and tiny tricks. Some things flopped hard. Some things popped fast. I also compared notes with another creator’s candid case study on boosting engagement, and it gave me a few extra ideas (here’s the study).

You want the real stuff? I’ll show you what I did, with my exact posts and numbers. Not magic. Just habits that stacked up. For a quick dive into what actually triggers the coveted tap, this breakdown helped me focus my experiments. To really understand what the Instagram algorithm is prioritizing right now, I studied this thorough guide and kept its ranking signals in mind as I tested.

The first change that made a dent

I started using a strong cover and a better time.

  • I picked covers with clear text. Big words. High contrast. Example: “5 Cozy Cafes Under $5” in white on a dark latte shot.
  • I posted when my people were online. My Insights showed 6 to 8 pm as hot. So I tried 6:30 pm most nights.

Result after week one:

  • Photo posts went from 120 likes to 180–220.
  • Reels jumped from 200–300 to 500–800 likes.

Not wild. But I felt it right away.

The stuff that really moved the needle

Let me explain what hit, and why I think it hit.

  1. Short Reels with a clear hook
    I kept Reels to 6–9 seconds. One idea per clip. First line in the caption told the point fast.
  • Example Reel: “Make cafe foam at home (no machine).”
    • Tools: iPhone 14 Pro, CapCut.
    • Audio: soft lo-fi, low volume.
    • Posted: Friday 6:40 pm.
    • Caption first line: “Stop wasting milk. Try this.”
    • Hashtags: #homecoffee #seattlecoffee #latteathome #kitchenhacks #coffeetime
    • Result: 1,200 likes, 340 saves, 210 shares, 96 new followers.

It was simple. Good light by the window. Close shots of the swirl. People saved it to try later. Saves seem to help reach. I can’t prove it. But I feel it.

  1. Carousels with a hook slide
    First slide needs to punch. Bold words. Clean image.
  • Example Carousel: “5 Cozy Seattle Cafes Under $5”
    • Slides: menu pics, close cups, quick notes (like “Quiet, good outlets”).
    • Posted: Tuesday 7:10 pm.
    • Result: 640 likes, 74 comments (“Which one has oat milk?”), 190 saves.
  1. Collab posts
    I used the Collab tool with a local bakery. My post showed on both feeds, so it reached new eyes.
  • Example Collab: Behind the scenes dough stretch with @SweetFernBakery.
    • Posted: Sunday 9:30 am.
    • Result: 2,100 likes, 420 shares, two custom order DMs for them, 230 new followers for me.

We both answered comments. It felt like a real chat, not just a reel.

  1. Faces and hands
    When my face or hands show, likes go up. It feels human. Wild, right? But true.

  2. Location tag every time
    Even on Reels. Folks in my city find me. And they stick.

One side note on location-based discovery: while Instagram helps me meet nearby latte lovers, plenty of people still use old-school classifieds to spark in-person connections. I found this candid walkthrough of how modern daters navigate Craigslist’s personals, Craigslist hookup guide, and it lays out real message examples, etiquette tips, and safety checklists for anyone curious about meeting someone IRL through that platform.

Real posts that worked (numbers and captions)

  • Reel: “3 ways to froth milk without a fancy machine”

    • Tools: CapCut template; iPhone mic plus a cheap clip-on (Boya BY-M1).
    • Posted: Friday 6:40 pm.
    • Caption: “No steamer? No problem. My fave is #2.”
    • Result: 1,200 likes, 340 saves, 210 shares, 96 followers.

  • Carousel: “Thrift date night fit (spent $28 total)”

    • Slides: mirror pic, price tags, quick fit math.
    • Posted: Wednesday 7:05 pm.
    • Hashtags: #seattlestyle #thriftfinds #outfitrepeater
    • Result: 680 likes, 61 comments, 120 saves.

  • Photo vs. Photo redo

    • First try: dark latte, 11 pm post. 110 likes.
    • Redo: same latte by the window at 10 am, light foam dusted with cocoa. 520 likes.

  • Story warm-up before posting

    • I ran a poll: “Cold brew or cappuccino?”
    • Then I posted a cold brew Reel 30 minutes later.
    • That Reel did 900 likes vs my usual 500–700. Maybe the poll warmed people up. That’s my guess.

What flopped for me (so you can skip it)

  • 30 random hashtags. Looked messy. Felt spammy. Reach dropped. Now I use 3 to 7, all tight to the topic.
  • Clickbait captions like “You won’t believe this.” People believed it… and scrolled.
  • Posting super late. My 11 pm posts sank.
  • Heavy filters. My skin looked orange. Coffee looked muddy. People liked natural tones way more.
  • Trend audio that didn’t fit my vibe. Views were high, but likes and follows were low. Wrong crowd.
  • Buying fake followers. I almost tried it, but this honest experiment scared me straight (read what happened).

My simple system now

It’s not fancy. But it sticks.

  • Post 3 times a week: 1 Reel, 1 Carousel, 1 Photo.
  • Warm up with 2–3 Stories the same day (poll or quick question).
  • Use window light. Clean background. Wipe the lens.
  • First caption line says the point fast. No fluff.
  • Add location tag. Add alt text.
  • Use 3–7 tight hashtags.
  • Reply to comments in the first hour. Ask a real question back.
  • Save the cover before posting, so the grid looks neat.
  • Track top posts in Insights. I sort by saves and shares. Then I repeat what works.

Time blocks help me: I batch film on Sundays, edit with CapCut, color in Lightroom Mobile, and schedule with Later. Later’s free plan is enough for me. I keep it simple. Plus, their team’s regularly updated in-depth write-up on the Instagram algorithm alerts me when it’s time to tweak my schedule or formats.

Tools I actually use

  • Phone: iPhone 14 Pro
  • Editing: CapCut (templates help), Lightroom Mobile (light touch)
  • Camera app: Halide for manual focus when I’m picky
  • Scheduler: Later (free plan)
  • Audio: Boya BY-M1 clip mic for voiceover
  • Light: cheap ring light, only at night
  • Username ideas: when friends ask, I send them this roundup of AI generators (see the roundup)

Pros: fast, cheap, easy. Cons: ring light can look harsh. CapCut text can look “template-y” if I don’t tweak it.

Quick notes that surprised me

  • A clear face cover gets more taps.
  • Blue and warm brown tones win on my feed.
  • Short Reels outperformed longer ones, most weeks.
  • A simple call to action helps. Example: “What do you order?” Comments doubled.

You know what? None of this is a trick. It’s small things stacked, day by day. Be clear. Be warm. Show hands. Show your town. Ask a true question. Then do it again next week.

If you try any of this, tag me on your post. I’ll cheer you on. And I’ll probably save it, too.

More posts